Counters
Free Counter Since April 24, 2008

Thursday, March 19, 2009

Yet More Nostalgia, This Time Not So Good

If you're not into old Genesis, you're obviously gonna just have to skip through my next dozen or so posts here. Don't worry, I'll take a break and go find some barely legal girl at a convenience store to hit on and pull this fucking thing back on track SOMETIME soon.

This 1970-1975 box I'm raving about has been out a few months. The other two have been out a while longer. A friend copied me the discs from the 1976-1982 box at the time, and I recently had got it out of the library and had my dad burn some of the DVD content. I had seen it again at the library last week, and was listening to the remix of Abacab in it when I drove to get the 70-75 box the other day.

I hadn't really listened to that 76-82 set. Here in the apartment, I either play CDs in the front room on a shitty boombox, or here at the computer in its speakers, which are good but not great. I have my stero here, the speakers are in place on the desk's upper level, but I've not hooked it up the entire time I've lived here. I think it's time I do, but I'm gonna have to do a lot of moving shit around to do that.

So the best place to listen to music is in the car, which is why I've not got all these Genesis remixes listened to yet.

On my last post, my friend Jeff (who I met on a Genesis discussion group, what, 12 years ago now?) left a comment about how he did NOT like the remix of A Trick Of The Tail. I'd only listened to it here in the apartment once and had merely thought it a bit odd.

So I went for a drive just now and listened to about 2/3rds of it, skipping through bits here and there.

Son of a bitch. You're right, Jeff. This is ANNOYING.

This is a definite case of gaining clarity at the expense of the atmosphere that makes an album work in the first place. Once again, everything is punchier and better defined, but there is a DISTINCT lack of warmth and atmosphere that was such a big part of what made A Trick Of The Tail work. It's a GREAT album. My personal favorites are The Lamb and Selling England, which are both flawed but wonderful. My next two favorites are probably the most PERFECT albums Genesis made - Foxtrot and Trick, neither of which have a single weak musical moment. Anyone who thinks the band went to hell when Gabriel left really needs another listen on A Trick Of The Tail.

But get the old "definitive edition remaster." While this new one isn't hideous, it just does not have nearly the character or life that the older version does. Which sucks, because the older one definitely could use a good upgrade.

Producers, do us a favor please - stop trying to make albums sound like they're in a fucking stadium. The drums on this new Trick (and to some extent the vocals) are just TOO upfront, too reverby, too much detached from the rest of the music. The clarity is wonderful. Getting that clarity by removing the organic glue that holds all the instruments together is NOT. Dance On A Volcano and Squonk had nice big drums to begin with, you didn't need to fuck with them like this.

Squonk is the one that pissed me off the most. That big Bonham-esque vibe is rendered plastic this time around. The drums just come out overbearing and obnoxious.

Ripples now has lost all the warmth and charm that I loved in it.

Los Endos didn't bother me as much, but there was actually one place where the drums should have been MORE upfront and were not (the moment when they kick back in during the big-ass 4/2 synth-fest), whereas the rest of the track they're right there.

The low end is brought up throughout this album, which would be nice if it didn't sound so artificially done.

And what the FUCK happened to the Mellotron in Entangled? That's one of the best uses of that instrument ever, and it's suddenly buried under ACOUSTIC GUITARS? And it's acoustic guitars that have been robbed of all their warmth, at that.

Fuck. I was having such a great time with those other albums.


On the other hand, when I heard the new Abacab the other day, I did like that one a hell of a lot. I've come to enjoy that album more over the years anyway, but it's always been a bit of a clusterfuck of bad early 80s production that makes you want to slap the shit out of Hugh Padgham and knock the turds out of his ears. The new one has one thing that sticks out to me - the guitars sound better. Not that they sound great, but better. There's times on that album you wouldn't even recognize a fucking guitar was there. It's still a weird sounding album that needed all the help it could get, but what the fuck.

So while Trick is fucked up now, I'll stick by loving the new Abacab, Trespass and Nursery Cryme, and what I've heard so far of Foxtrot. I'll get to the rest later.

Love,
Arizona Bay
PS Tomorrow night I'm going to the 50th birthday party of my friend who I saw Yes with a few months ago. He told me to bring the boxes along - we can hear the DTS mixes on the DVDs at his place. So I'm looking forward to that.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

I've heard that in the late 70s, there was supposedly a trend in record production where the engineers would mix a lot of the instruments at an even level to make them blend together for a more "muddy" sound. I think this is what Genesis/David Hentschel were trying to do in that era. It works rather well on Trick, but not so well on Wind & Wuthering and it's an absolute disaster on And Then There Were Three.

I get the impression from listening to Trick 2007 that they were overcompensating for the muddiness of these albums by doing just the opposite -- make them as crisp and clear as possible. But the overall effect is, as you said, rather artificial sounding.

People often complain about Hackett being mixed too low, and that's understandable in a lot of ways, but again, that subtlety was part of his character. I always liked those little riffs he plays in the background on the Robbery verses. On the new remaster, they're way too obvious.

I *like* subtlety -- I love it when a little detail is mixed down a bit so that you may not notice it the first time you listen to it, but it catches you later on. (That's what I love about "Tanzmusik" on that Kraftwerk album -- there's just oodles of little things going on in that song that you can hear something new every time, yet it doesn't sound too cluttered. PG's Digging In The Dirt is great for that kind of thing as well.)

But it seems that Trick may have been one of the few missteps this time around. I'll check out the Gabe stuff when I get a chance.

And yeah, I agree that Ripples was totally butchered. Actually, I think all the mellow songs were. (Why the hell did they make the chorus of Entangled sound like there's a whole male choir singing behind Phil? Uggh.)

Arizona Bay said...

I have a feeling that the remixes I'll like will be the albums that needed the most help to begin with, and the ones that I liked the sound of already are gonna be a nightmare.

So now I have to deal with THAT thought going into Selling England and The Lamb. I may have to drink to survive those ones.

I like that subtlety too. it's a big part of what makes their best music work. I think it's just a matter of how it's handled. I love that I can now tell what the fuck the 12-strings are doing on the early stuff, and I think their essential "woody" quality remains. But then there's the 12-strings on Trick, which just sound plastic now.

If I was doing these mixes...well, it would be shit, since I don't have a clue what the fuck I'm doing and anyone who's heard my crappy demos knows that already...but if someone was there to HELP me remix those albums, I'd likely spend a lot of time on Hackett's parts trying to find a way of bringing out some definition without necessarily making them LOUDER. My complaint about how Hackett is mixed has more to do with the overall production of the albums that don't sound so hot. I think Wind & Wuthering is just too "wooshy" and it fucks with those little bits here and there that he's doing.

You're dead on with And Then There Were Three. I kinda think I'm gonna like whatever they do to that )I'm going through these in order, so it will be a while) even if it is a dumbass heavy-handed job, just because that album sounds like a fucking mess to begin with.

This trend to crank the shit out of everything is amazingly stupid. If you're doing crazy-thick heavy metal, it MIGHT be a good idea. (And I'm not so sure about that either.) But to take music that has so much detail and nuance, where dynamics and colour are so important, and shove that into your fucking face...what the fuck are people THINKING?

Holy shit, Jeff. We haven't talked about Genesis this much together in years. :)