I've found it necessary to listen to the 1970-1975 Genesis box in the car to appreciate it, because I' don't have my good speakers hooked up inside. The computer speakers I have are good, but not great. Out in the car, I'm much better able to hear shit.
Trespass is the real gem here, I can tell already. It's just mindfuckingly awesome how much better it is.
Nursery Cryme isn't as radical a difference, but it's certainly better. The vocals sound wonderful now, backing vocals are much clearer, a couple harmonies are there I've never heard before. (A very subtle high harmony towards the end of The Fountain Of Salmacis I've not heard before made my dick hard. I swear it did.) My only complaint is the reverb on Gabriel on the end of The Return of The Giant Hogweed (otherwise, the last half of that piece - one of my favorite things they ever did - kicks glorious amounts of whale-ass in this new version) which i found distracting.
I've watched the 2007 interviews on the DVDs for those two and Foxtrot. Interesting and enjoyable. And I can't fathom what it would be like if I had DTS to enjoy the album as it is on THOSE discs.
I've listened to two Foxtrot tracks in the car. Watcher Of The Skies is gorgeous. nothing amazingly different, but definitely punchier.
Get 'Em out By Friday is another of my very favorite songs of theirs. Gabriel's vocal is SO much better on this mix. All around clarity and punch that knocks the old versions into a shitty little hat.
But what DESTROYED me, and it's really such a little thing, is towards the end of the song. Just after you're informed of the four-foot restriction on humanoid height (gawd, Peter Gabriel is one twisted fuck, and I love him for it) you can hear in the background during the next section the sounds of people in the background. This has always been there, an interesting subliminal touch to that part of the song. But on the new mixes you can REALLY hear it. There's nuance and detail to this "musique concrete" on the level of a Pink Floyd recording. It's such a subtle thing, and it made my jaw drop.
I've been SHAKING for half an hour now. I can't believe that this - the music that made me into a musician and is still some of the most rewarding listening for me - is now so new again. It's been almost 25 years since I (over ten years late) was introduced to Genesis' best work. I feel like I've been given a gift. I feel like I'm 16 again.
And I don't have to let that Invisible Touch horseshit get in the way. Wheeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!
Love,
Arizona Bay
---
By the way, it was four years ago today - right about this time - that I was packing my bags on the last day I lived with my daugther and her mother. I'm gonna go blast more of Foxtrot and not think too much about that.
-----
Just watched the interviews on the Selling England DVD. You know, it's a little hard to listen to Rutherford talk about old pieces being "a bit busy" given how much tepid under-developed SHIT he's inflicted on people once he "matured." OK, Moonlit Knight is "busy". And the fucking Mechanics should be dipped in motor oil and set on FIRE, you scrawny assbag. I'm beginning to realize that for all his sins against the listening public, I might actually have a real good time hanging out with Phil Collins, and I might just fall asleep in a room that has Rutherford and Banks in it. It's remarkable how CLUELESS they've become about their own work over the years.
As I've watched these interviews, I've been dicking around with my 12-string. I have the beginnings of a little "tribute" of sorts that I can't wait to flesh out and make "a bit busy." Some nice major/minor contrasts if I do say so myself.
------
Interviews on The Lamb DVD watched. Collins made a comparison that struck me as so utterly bizarre until I thought about it - how the actual sound of parts of The Lamb is not unlike Neil Young's live-in-the-barn recordings. (Phil says with Crazy Horse, but I'm sure he's thinking of the Stray Gators and Harvest.) You know what? He has a point there. A bit of a stretch, but I get it.
It's pretty easy to see how the band can be ambivalent about parts of The Lamb, hell, it baffles the snot out of most of the people who listen to the damn thing. But it's my personal favorite of their albums simply because they pushed things so far, did something so very much a part of that time with no apparent regard for anything other than making a good piece of work. It's a very HONEST album. It's full of flaws, bits that go on too long or don't work too well, and Hackett is there maybe 16% of the time (though when he is, he's fucking fantastic) and the whole thing is just so fucking TWISTED, but why not? I wish more people would push their shit that far, and if it's not so perfect, it really doesn't goddamn matter, does it? I'll always respect balls over getting every damn thing in its place, even though some people can do both very well. I like Phil's comparison to Neil Young in the context of these interviews where Tony Banks mentions Crosby, Stills, & Nash several times as an influence. Genesis, like CSN, can make really, really wonderful albums with every single thing in its place. But maybe sometimes they can use a Neil Young to stomp around and fuck up the edges a bit. The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway is the Neil Young to the CSN-like perfection of many other albums. And maybe that's why I love it so much. Though I'm pretty sure I don't want to hear Neil sing The Colony Of Slippermen...
Wednesday, March 18, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



4 comments:
Maybe I will check out that boxed set for myself. What I've heard at least in mp3 format sounds pretty damn good.
I don't know about you, but I was horrified by the 2007 remaster of Trick of the Tail. It seems like they cranked up the volume on everything, added a bunch of unnecessary reverb and compressed everything to death. That kind of approach might work for some recordings, but not Trick. The older masters weren't perfect, but they had a warmth and subtlety that I felt was totally butchered.
After hearing that, I was afraid to buy any other remasters...but hearing some pieces of the 1970-75 stuff might give me a change of heart.
I honestly haven't taken a good enough listen to the 76-82 stuff. A friend bought it and burned me copies, and I played them on shittier speakers and only thought "hmmm, odd mix there, I doubt I'll like this as much" and only listened to my old copies in the car. (I've got burns of the last versions that I added all the extra tracks to the end of.)
So I haven't really listened to the new Trick (the one post-Gabriel album I love every bit as much as the ones with him and more than a couple of them) and I'm slightly scared to. But I did snag that box from the library just before getting the Gabriel-era one, and I have to say that I DID like the one new CD I listened to in the car - Abacab. It's not a huge difference, but the guitars sound better. Those little melodic bits that aren't anything amazing but add a bit of color, and they sound better now. Also, there's this little distorted klunge of a one-chord riff in Dodo that Rutherford does that is dirt-simple, but in the new mix you can really HEAR it. I liked that a lot.
I know the tendency today is to crank the fuck out of everything, so I'm now more worried about listening to Trick. I don't need to hear that.
I DO think the bottom end on these CDs is still a little odd. The drums are brought up in a way that I'm not sure yet that I'll love as much after more listens. I like loud drums. I'm not sure abut the WAY they are made louder once the rest of the mix is in place. This is most noticeable of the ones I've heard on Trespass. As fucking beautiful of a job as they did, it does emphasize just how bad of a match that drum sound was to the rest of the instruments on the album. I find I'm far less bothered by Mayhew's playing as I used to be (though it is pretty damn stuff) as I am that damn drum sound that doesn't fit well. It's a flaw in the original album that they seem to have gone back and done the best they can with, and I honestly can't imagine how they'd improve it, but it is noticeable.
it's also very strange to think that the guy who did these mixes also had to work with a bass track of MINE on a shitty live CD ten years ago that a few hundred people own. That's a very weird mindfuck in itself. I've seen The Farm (from the road, didn't go in) and I'd love to sit in there and hear all these albums the way THEY get to hear them. Can you imagine having the opportunity to listen to say, just one 12-string track from Supper's Ready soloed out by itself? Fuck, that thought makes my dick hard.
I liked Invisible Touch. Phil Collins is my tiny, drum-playing God and I won't hear a word against his masterwork. ;)
Splunge!
Post a Comment