Read the final chapter of the Gospel of Mark. As I've stated here before, it's agreed on by a vast majority of scholars that the last several verses were added later - that the end of the story is that the women who arrive at Jesus' tomb never tell anyone what they saw. A weird ending if you're used to Christian dogma, but the ending in all the best and most complete manuscripts - Jesus comes back from the dead, and other than the women who show up after he's left, NO ONE EVER FINDS OUT.
Then look at the story of Jesus praying in the Garden Of Gethsemane in chapter 14. He prays alone. ALONE. Nobody is there when Jesus asks the Father to take this cup from him if it is his will, to not make him go through this shit. I really like this story. It's certainly more believable and human than what you find in the other gospels - Jesus DOESN'T WANT TO FUCKING DIE. He'll do it if he has to, but he asks his God to spare him if it's His will. Makes a lot more sense than strolling up to Pilate saying "Crucify me, dammit."
But he prays this ALONE. So how does Mark know? How does Mark know that Jesus was resurrected if the women at the tomb told nobody? Isn't it HIGHLY PRESUMPTIOUS of Christian apologists to assume that they DID tell anyone? Remember that Mark is the earliest gospel and that Matthew and Luke are clearly dependent on it, and that a good case can be made for John's dependence on at least parts of it. (Never mind that John's is even more blatantly fictitious, we'll deal with that another time.) The later stories of Jesus appearing to his disciples can very easily be shown to be pulled directly from the asses of the authors, dealing with what they saw as the big problem of Mark not having such stories. (The best discussion of this topic I've seen is in Robert M. Price's The Incredible Shrinking Son Of Man.)
Could it be...could it just MAYBE fuckin' be, that Mark is TELLING A STORY? That he's not even trying to impart actual historical information, but is merely MAKING SHIT UP? You know, what writers DO sometimes? Could it be that The Gospel Of Mark WAS NEVER INTENDED TO BE ANYTHING BUT FICTION???
Read it sometime. Me, I've come to really enjoy the thing. Throwing down the burden of having to take it anymore seriously than I do an episode of Spongebob helps. A LOT.
Love,
Arizona Bay
Wednesday, September 23, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



9 comments:
You never fail to amaze me. It's as if you read a story about a 20 foot tall bunny rabbit with flaming farts who rampaged through Manhattan in 1910, wearing Adidas sneakers and a purple fedora, shouting racial slurs and playing a ukulele, and after some careful study you'd point out how this is obviously fiction, since Adidas sneakers didn't exist in 1910.
WHAT ABOUT THE BIG FUCKING BUNNY RABBIT?
Dude, get real. You're talking about Christianity. This bunny rabbit story is believed (and seldom actually read) by a FUCK of a lot of people and has been for eons. It's been pounded into the heads of people since their heads were soft for a couple thousand years. You Jews have weird shit like a sense of history and a bullshit detector. don't assume WE do. People think this shit HAPPENED. They also think Obama is trying to kill their grandma and UFOs are waiting to probe their assholes. Just because something is fucking stupid doesn't stop SHIT.
Anyway, I'm dealing with specifics here. Any idiot (which is to say person not indoctrinated by Christian dogma) can figure out this is all bullshit on a general level, I'm going point by point. It's fun for me. It's intellectually satisfying. And anyway, you missed my point, which wasn't that it's bullshit, but that it was never intended to be anything else. This is not something recognized by very many people, believers or not, which is how you end up with liberals trying to conflate Jesus with their views just as conservatives do (read a recent interview with Michael Moore if you're in the mood for that kind of stupidity), and how you end up with atheists who (like I did a few years ago before actually reading the shit) think the Bible is some terrible thing. It isn't. It's fun literature full of all sorts of curveballs for the few of us who give a shit. This is MICRO work I'm doing here, not macro. It's not even about disproving it per se, I'm enjoying the FUCK out of reading this stuff.
Anyone can figure out it's nonsense, I'm interested in going point by point as to why it is and why it got to be that way. I know this kind of thing is a waste of time for people who actually have sex more than once a year, but come on, have you read those fuckers who take apart Homer and Shakespeare? What I'm doing is no different. And those guys never get their dick sucked either. It's a fine tradition, dammit.
First, way to spin me getting laid as an intellectual liability. Twelve points.
Second, I still prefer this to the gay erotica Harry Potter fan fiction. Do yourself a favor and don't look it up.
1.) Send me someone who'll suck my cock and I'll throw down that fucking Bible in a heartbeat. Liability? FUCK.
2.) My kid told me the other night that she's reading Harry potter And The Deathly hallows, which I haven't read yet, but I'm in awe of an 8 year old tackling something like that. I'm probably going to introduce her to Edgar Allen Poe soon. I got a good solid glance at my daughter's desire to explore darker alleys this week, and I think it's BEAUTIFUL.
But I'm not bothering with the gay Potter fan fic. I don't need to imagine Alan Rickman taking it up the ass from...well...anyone.
Heh. My kid read Moby Dick when he was eight. He thought it was boring, except for the parts about whaling. Strangely enough, I understand that this is what critics said when the book was first published. I think Henry F. Chorley's review here says basically the same thing. I think.
I never even tried Moby Dick. Well, I might have seen a porn flick by that name, but...
More macro scale, but I got a copy of Religulous last night. Have you seen that one?
Not yet, and I know I'll enjoy it, but knowing the way Maher went about making it (essentailly the same thing Ben Stein did with Exposed, not letting people he was interviewing in on what he was actually doing) bugs the shit out of me. I love Maher, but he's a real cunt sometimes. But I bet I'll like it anyway.
It's a good book. You should read it. If nothing else, you'll get a clam chowder recipe out of it.
Post a Comment