Counters
Free Counter Since April 24, 2008

Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Hey, Does Anyone Have A Pair Of Pliers?

Matthew 27:35 And when they had crucified Him, they divided up His garments...

Mark 15: 24 - And they crucified Him, and divided up his garments...

Luke 23:33 - When they came to the place called The Skull, there they crucified Him and the criminals, one on the right and the other on the left.

John 19:18 - There they crucified Him, and with Him two other men, one on either side, and Jesus in between.



Notice something interesting here. We now know that crucifixion was not always done with nails, that sometimes people were TIED to a cross. Not one of these verses actually says which method was used.

So where does the idea of Jesus being nailed to a cross come from? One place:

John 20:24-25 - But Thomas, one of the twelve, called Didymus, was not with them when Jesus came. So the other disciples were saying to him, "We have seen the Lord!" But he said to them, :Unless I see in His hands the imprints of the nails, and put my finger into the place of the nails, and put my hand into His side, I will not believe."


By the way, when Jesus comes and invites Thomas to do this weird shit ("Hey, I need to check out his extra HOLES!" It sounds like a fucking Stanhope joke, for Christ's sake.), it doesn't say that Thomas actually DID, just that he answered and said to Jesus, "My Lord and my God!"


It might be interesting to note a few things, not the least of which I've said many times before: that these are separate accounts written in different times by different people. Also that "John's" book definitely represents a view of Jesus from well after Mark's time. Most scholars believe it was written last out of the four, though I've recently read some compelling ideas about Luke's account - and the book of Acts, which is also attributed to Luke - coming from as late as around 200AD. There was certainly an earlier version of Luke known to Marcion around 140-150, but it appears to some scholars that it was added to later. This is complicated shit, by the way. In fact, there's a school of thought that says Marcion - condemned as a heretic by later "orthodox" writers - INVENTED Paul and his letters, which the orthodox later had to fit into their own shit since theese letters were so popular. And it's not a crazy idea, there's some damn good thought behind it.Read this for more info:

http://depts.drew.edu/jhc/detering.html

Also know that the book of John appears to have been compiled from at least a few different sources. The beginning is a VERY different writing style than the rest, much more poetic. Just a few verses after the above story of Thomas, chapter 20 ends in such a way as to suggest the end of the entire work. Then comes chapter 21 (these divisions NOT being made in these ways at the time of writing) in a rather awkward way that suggests it was tacked onto the end of an earlier work, much the same way as the final verses of Mark after the women leave the tomb are clearly a LATER addition.

Something that has become clear to scholars is that not only are there various, sometimes conflicting, views of Jesus scattered about the New Testament, but that some of these supposed authors are reacting to other people's views by working those views into their writings as something Jesus himself speaks against. John's gospel most certainly shows this. Also note the HUGE difference in tone between John's and the other three canonical gospels, quite striking as in the case of who Jesus actually is. In Mark's gospel, Jesus actually tells people to NOT tell anyone who he really is. But in John, almost all Jesus does is tell everyone around exactly who the fuck he is. The two stories simply do not compute. Mark's Jesus is quite human. John's can very well be considered to be an entirely cosmic figure, and John is written in such a way that it is VERY hard for a rational person to conclude this was EVER meant to be anything like a historical report.

There is a Gospel Of Thomas as well, not in the New Testament, but which has received a lot of press in recent years. One thing that many scholars note is that John's gospel in places seems to be an answer, even a refutation of what "Thomas" supposedly had to say. If one reads the Thomas gospel - which is merely a collection of Jesus' sayings, without any of the miracle stories of the four canonical gosepls, or the heavily advanced Christology of John's - you are almost reading a different character than John's, and there are specific sayings quite unlike anything you will read in any of the canonical four.

(Check out saying 114 - Simon Peter said to them, "Mary should leave us, for females are not worthy of life." Jesus said, "See, I am going to attract her to make her male so that she too might become a living spirit that resembles you males. For every female (element) that makes itself male will enter the kingdom of heaven.")

Not exactly much help to "feminist" versions of Christ...

The gospel of Thomas appears to many to come from either the same time as the other gospels or soon after, but it is interesting to note that of the four NT works, only John puts words in Thomas' mouth, and they are used to make Thomas look like he needs some fuckin' advice. It would appear that people who held to a "Thomasine" Christianity were being told by a "Johannine" version to get their shit together. There is debate on what this means, some (such as Elaine Pagels in her recent book Beyond Belief) arguing that Thomasine Christians did not beliee Jesus was physically raised from the dead, only spiritually. We know some early Christians believed this, certainly many Gnostics.

But there are a lot of overlaps and inconsistencies here, and Thomas' gospel does not really read that much like later Gnostic texts, which presuppose a whole story of creation and man's relationship to God that is quite different than today's Christianity. Funnily enough, there are traces of this within John's gospel. And Paul's writings. Again, this is complicated shit.

I'm currently working through a chapter in Robert M. Price's Jesus Is Dead about this topic, and he has a lot to say about it. He even goes so far as to suggest that the "Judas Didymus Thomas" of the Thomas gospel (Thomas means "twin", and certain Syrian groups believed that he was Jesus' twin brother) and Judas Iscariot were originally held to be the same person, the two being taken apart and further mythologized by later "orthodox" Christians. Who knows. At any tate, I thought I'd throw some of this shit out there for the consideration of any of my readers who care about such things.

One more interesting tidbit. Here's a verse from the Thomas gospel:

His disciples said to him, "Is circumcision useful or not?" He said to them, "If it were useful, their father would produce children already circumcised from their mother. Rather, the true circumcision in spirit has become profitable in every respect."

This sounds a lot like Paul. It also begs a question: would ANYONE in the time of Jesus even ask this fucking question? If, as we are so often led to believe, Jesus and his followers in his own time were Jews, would this have been ANY kind of topic of discussion? The debate over circumcision could ONLY have taken place well after the death of any historical Jesus that might have existed (there certainly is not any recorded discussion of it until Paul and Thomas show up), only when the "mission to the Gentiles" began, and people who weren't Jews would have said, "Hey, wait a fucking minute, this Jesus guy sounds fine, but you want to cut WHAT off???" Like many other things in the Bible and books just outside it, this entire topic put into the supposed time of Jesus himself (much like synagogues in Galilee, for which there is NO pre-AD70 evidence of) is an anachronism, something that cannot be taken seriously as a saying of any historical Jesus that might have existed. (And if you've read my shit, probably didn't.)

Enjoy, fuckers!

Love and nails,
Arizona Bay

No comments: