Robert M. Price's book is fucking with me. And I like it.
I'm increasingly becoming both irritable and overjoyed at the prospects ot the book I've been talking about writing. Continued research is making something very clear - I don't know SHIT.
The very core of the book I intend to write about Jesus is founded on the notion that you cannot possibly have an intelligent conversation about either the man or the material written about him without putting them into their historical context of the Jewish people of the first century.
And my knowledge of that is increasingly proven to be lame as all fuck. I'm learning more about the people, their rulers, and the ridiculous number of books that were NOT included within their scriptures, books that are seemingly much more important to an understanding of early Christianity than I thought.
Add into that the "pagan" world surrounding them as part of the Roman empire, a world that provided the spark for pretty much every single "miraculous" story you read about Jesus, and you've got a huge amount of shit to sift through to come to any reasonable understanding of the context in which Christianity came to be.
This is fascinating stuff to me. I've always loved history, partly because I've always had the feeling I was being lied to in some way about the details. Nowhere is this more evident than in the history of Christianity - there is SO much you are NEVER told in church.
I was accused elsewhere this week by a Christian friend of mine of being "uninformed." The absurdity is catching up to me. Yeah, I really AM. Because we ALL are. How many Christians know enough of the history of those times to be able to spot the glaring piles of historically inaccurate bullshit within the New Testament?
Here's one for ya:
And it came to pass in those days, that there went out a decree from Caesar Augustus, that all the world should be taxed. [And] this taxing was first made when Cyrenius was governor of Syria.) And all went to be taxed, every one into his own city. And Joseph also went up from Galilee, out of the city of Nazareth, into Judaea, unto the city of David, which is called Bethlehem; (because he was of the house and lineage of David:) To be taxed with Mary his espoused wife, being great with child. - Luke 2:1-5
There's a problem. Luke says in his first chapter that Jesus was born during the reign of Herod The Great. But "Cyrenius" (AKA Quirinius) was not governor then. (Herod was a local "client king" of the Roman Empire, Quirinius the Roman governor of Syria) He did not become governor until AFTER Herod had died. There is NO record of the kind of census Luke talks about here, and in fact the census that WAS taken under Quirinius was an outrage among Jews, who rioted, leaving thousands dead. What the fuck is up with this otherwise unknown census ten years previous?
How many "believers" bother to question Luke's assertion that Mary and Joseph went to Bethlehem (a trip itself apparently an invention of Luke to "fulfill prophecy", because Luke had the MISTAKEN idea that the "Messiah" was supposed to come from there according to scripture) for a census that is recorded NOWHERE ELSE in history, and in fact is patently absurd? Look at the details. Does ANYONE hold a census wherein you're supposed to go to where your "ancestors" lived? That's what Luke says. Joseph went there because of being of the "lineage" of David. Well, what does THAT mean? People, you have a LOT of ancestors.
WHICH ancestors do you pick? The one that just so happened to be King Of The Jews? hey, I'm a fucking Gentile. I ain't seeing the king of ANYWHERE in MY family tree. Maybe the king of a bunch of cornfields in Indiana, that's about it. Maybe it's supposed to be just the exclusively male line you come down from. But how do you know even all THAT?
How would every person in the empire at that time even KNOW where these "ancestors" lived? What do you mean by "lived"? Where they were born, died, or spent most of their lives? What if they traveled a lot? Boy and girls, each and every one of you has SIXTEEN great-great-grandparents. And that's only going back THAT far. I have gg-grandparents who died less than a hundred fucking years ago. That doesn't even get CLOSE to how far removed Joseph was from David. Even if it WAS supposed to be just the male line down (excluding the females of course, since they don't count) do you know how many fucking descendants one person could have across a thousand years when everyone is having a dozen fucking kids? No WONDER there's "no room at the inn" for fuck's sake. That's a LOT of fucking people.
Do you know where your ancestors lived? Well, when it comes to great-great-grandparents, some of mine lived in the county where I was born, were also born and died and buried there. One set lived south of Indianapolis and the husband died young but I don't have the first fucking clue where and how and where he's buried. One set had a man born in North Carolina who moved near Richmond, Indiana then to somwhere near Westfield, Indiana, then to Attica, Indiana and then around Lafayette, Indiana. His wife was born somewhere very near where the international airport is in Indianapolis, but Quaker records show her family constantly changing which meetings they were part of throughout both Marion and Hamilton counties (her Dad, supposedlyu born in Ohio, briefly attended a Quaker meeting HALF A MILE from where I lived most of my childhood an hour north of Indy, then moved to fucking IOWA) before she married her husband in Hamilton County, then moved on from there. I've only known this for about FIVE YEARS. And then only because I took the time to LOOK for it. Looking at this set of great-great-grandparents, not even counting him living in North Carolina, there are FIVE counties in Indiana they lived in. Which one do I go to for this census? And what about the other FOURTEEN great-great-grandparents? Do I just ignore them? And if I choose others because they "lived" in the county I did until I turned thirty (having moved out myself eight years ago), what about these others? And that's just great-great-grandparents. What about the "ancestors" before them? What about where THEY "lived?" What about the ggggg-grandfather who was born in EUROPE and died in Pennsylvania? What about the one who was born in England and died at sea? If death is worth anything in this census, do I go get a fucking ship and LOOK for this guy who they threw overboard three hundred years ago? What about the simple fact the the only reason a government even does a census is so that they know where YOU are right NOW? Who has TIME for any of this shit when you live in an ancient world where 90% of the people are illiterate and there's no such thing as indoor plumbing?
This insane creation of Luke's is utterly useless as history. And is only the tip of the iceberg. So much nonsense is within the Gospels it would take a book - in fact, the many books already on the market on the very topic that I'm sifting through now - to detail it all. The example above is a hoot. The list of further examples is extensive. We haven't even got to the conflicting reports of when exactly Jesus died and how many people showed up at the front door of Rolling Rock's brewery to check up on the missing corpse. Those details are different in EVERY gospel.
I'm in awe of how much lies before me. And as frustrating as it is - I will NOT publish a fucking thing until I know I've got as much facts together as possible - it's also one FUCK of a lot of fun. This is entertaining shit, kids. And not just because it knocks all of our preconceptions about Jesus into a very shitty little hat. But because it's HISTORY. I like that. I like learning shit.
I'm climbing up an ever-growing mountain of evidence and non-evidence towards a summit where I can stand with a guy we like to call "The Historical Jesus." The REAL guy, the one buried underneath all the bullshit. Unfortunately, I'm discovering that I might have to stand up there alone. There seems to be increasingly little I can say with any confidence about who this guy REALLY was, where the line between the stories made up about him and the real guy actually lies. It seems very likely to me that the most important figure in Western culture never even fucking existed. In a way, that's kind of disappointing to me. The idea of a delusional paranoid Hal Lindsay-esque freak with asshole-like "morals" ("Fuck burying your dead! Follow ME!") was appealing very strongly to me. But that is the way of both history and science. Don't hold too tight to your theories until you are confident in the evidence. And it seems to me that the evidence - or rather, the complete lack thereof - for a historical Jesus, let alone one worth basing a religion on, is overwhelming.
Yet "he" still pervades our society to this day. Not bad for a 2000-year old myth.
Love,
Arizona Bay
-----
Price makes a reference to Lovecraft in this book, when discussing legends of Jesus traveling to India. Then, while talking about his relation to John The Baptist, he makes a reference to Python's Life Of Brian. I REALLY like this guy, even though he's pulling the rug out from under my own hypothesis on Christ more and more with each page. I LOVE people who make me think and are funny about it.
Wednesday, May 21, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



No comments:
Post a Comment