In my research on Jesus and the early Christian writings, I've discovered some interesting things about the four "canonical" gospels, including when and where they were written. it is clear to the vast majority of serious scholars that Mark was written first - Matthew and Luke quote from him extensively, and John has many features that show a still later date.
A historian interested in finding actual facts will always consider an earlier writing to have a certain credibility, and in fact, Mark reads in such a way as to make it far more palatable to those of us who have a problem with the nonsense of the later gospels - the details of Jesus' early life were all added later, and clearly lifted from pagan myth, and even the story of the resurrection is free of too much excess bullshit, since the earliest versions of Mark do not have Jesus appearing to anyone or "ascending." The final verses of Mark dealing with these events have been proven to been added on later.
It has a certain starkness to it and shows a much more human Jesus. Certainly the crucifixion story is more believable in Mark's context - Jesus is FUCKED and he KNOWS it. There's actual pain and torment in Mark, which lends a credibility to it that none of the other gospels have, even though there is still much obvious nonsense in it.
But some of the nonsense isn't so obvious to many of us today, especially those of us who don't know much if anything about Judaism and specifically the Jews of Jesus' own time. It turns out that there are numerous bizarre errors in Mark that only a non-jew could have come up with. Not only was the person writing this (whatever his name, "Mark" is a result of tradition, and the gospel itself is anonymous) not a Jew, he doesn't even get his shit straight. He displays an ignorance of the geography of the area, he misunderstands Jewish law, and he even misquotes the fucking ten commandments, for fuck's sake.
Here is a website that details much of Mark's bullshit, clearly showing that this "gospel" was as "inspired by God" as a fucking Bush State Of The Union address is:
http://www.vexen.co.uk/religion/mark.html
Fun stuff if you're into it.
Love,
Arizona Bay
Wednesday, January 30, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



2 comments:
That's kinda neat. I passed the url to my daughter, she spent a lot of time a year or two ago researching what's factually known, if anything, about the bible and ole jc.
My untestable hypothesis about xianity is this...
Communion, I really think, might really be something Jesus (if he did exist) did teach. He may have thought, "My words are going to be twisted, and everything turned into a mockery of what I'm saying."
He probably had Manson Family type groupies by then, so he creates this serious little "ritual" in which his idiot followers eat his body and drink his blood. He was fucking MOCKING them, and they didn't get it, and passed it along, and now the message is still there, as intended: don't believe what was written about him, those around him were fucking bloodsucking religious nuts.
Odds are, I'm wrong. But why else, at the peak of your fame, would you teach ritual cannibalism and vampirism, and tell them "do this in remembrance of me" and pass it on?
This didn't go over well with the minister of a Baptist church, but at least when I told him of this he didn't take a swing at me.
That's an interesting thought, but actually communion was yet another feature of various "pagan" rituals of the time that early Christians lifted and grafted onto their own shit. In fact (and I don't have the info in front of me, I can't remember the specific verse) it's been shown that the most explicit directions Christ supposedly gave for thie ritual were added onto the text later - the earliest version of that gospel (whichever one it was, can't remember) do NOT have that in there.
So there is no way of knowing if he actually did have his followers do this, and in all likelihood he didn't. One major thing to remember about Jesus is that he was thoroughly Jewish. Communion not having anything to do with Judaism, and Jesus not being even remotely interested in starting anything new - his primary message was that it was all going to end soon - I don't see how any of this lines up.
I doubt he was too worried about his words getting twisted since he thought everything was coming to an end within a very short of time anyway. Still, your idea is a fun one to throw at Baptists. :)
Post a Comment