http://www.snopes.com/politics/religion/compass.asp
Because, after all, when religious people make movies and push their shit, it's fine, but when atheists do it, we're assholes. Gee, I think I'll take my six-year old to see Mel Gibson's violent guilt-fest BEFORE exposing her to anything resembling rational thought! What a great fuckin' American idea!
Love,
Arizona Bay
Sunday, November 4, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



2 comments:
That's funny. First, the books are awesome, and you should read them.
I picked up on the anti religious theme, but couldn't really characterize it at first - it was obviously anti church, but it used religious ideas and motifs to keep me wondering for a while.
As far as the comparison to C. S. Lewis goes, I read the Narnia books when I was very young and completely ignorant of Christianity, so the rather blatant preaching went WAY over my head. I enjoyed the books a great deal, but when I tried to read them recently, I couldn't stomach that aspect of them anymore, and put them down.
Either way, I think The Golden Compass is very well written, tells a better story than any of the Narnia tales, and is probably better for your health in the long term.
As for the movie, I usually avoid anything with Nicole Kidman, but I'll make an exception for this one, even if it can't possibly do any justice to the book.
I recently re-read the first Narnia book and found I liked it about half as much as I used to. I don't have a real problem with it, but it's simply nowhere near as strong a story as I'd previously thought of it as.
I have a soft spot in my heart for C.S. Lewis though. When I was deep into fundamentalism, everyone told me his book Mere Christianity was the best book to convert others to Jesus. When *I* read it, it pretty much punched a thousand holes in what I thought I believed and started me down the path to questioning religion and eventually becoming an atheist. His "Christian apologism" is really quite lame and easily torn apart.
But I liked his sci-fi trilogy a lot too, so...
Post a Comment