I've been downloading a lot of old prog-rock stuff, and a lot of what got called that in the 80s and 90s. Some of it is fucking cool. I just heard Anekdoten for the first time, a Swedish band who liked their old King Crimson albums a fuck of a lot, apparantly.There's the good example.
But man, the 80s sure sucked for prog-rock, eh? Avoid the band Pendragon like the plague.I don't know what the fuck happened in Britian in the 80s to make everyone suck so bad, but this group of 8th-graders who think Tolkein novels were history textbooks REALLY deserve mention for being every fucking thing that can possibly go wrong with "progressive rock." The reason Yes got away with being pompous was they had IDEAS. Picking three Important Sounding chords to play through your whooshy-ass synth patch while your guitar players jizzes on his delay pedal ISN'T PROGRESSIVE. It is POO. This is the shit that could make you want to pull out Journey or Asia albums for something on the avant-garde side, for Christ's sake. Arena-splooge mixed with prog-rock is still ARENA-SPLOOGE. Add in brilliant lyrical masterstrokes like "Girl meets boy, boy meets girl/A new love born, together they're gonna change the world" and you might reconsider the merits of Invisible Touch and GTR.
If you want to hear the inside of the assholes of some people who are likely doomed to get even less pussy than me, go download a Pendragon album. Otherwise, somebody call Steve Perry and tell him I'm sorry - I was wrong, and there is somebody more annoying than him and Dennis DeYoung combined. My bad, Steve.
Christ, I need some Beefheart now just to feel human again.
Love,
Arizona Bay
Monday, March 12, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



9 comments:
Am I a bad person because I like "Invisible Touch"?
Also avoid Metamorfosi (Italian "prog") and Pallas (UK). Take my word for it.
For me these bands (or at least some of their albums) are something of a guilty pleasure. I don't listen to them often, but they do get dusted down every once in a while. Like (almost) any form of music - there is some good amongst the legions of crap.
You need to remember that we'd had a wonderful 10+ years of great music (some of it even having chart success), then punk hit to shake things up and it was almost as though instead of fighting back, the great proggers turned things down a notch or seven. Genesis crossed over to the mainstream, Yes had severe identity problems, Tull swallowed a truckload of sequencers and many others went into hiding!
Into this came a generation of musos brought up on the heyday of early 70's prog, so we got a bunch of neo-prog bands trying to keep the dream alive, but against a tide of dwindling audiences and apathy for good new music. Marillion were really the only ones with any success, with the likes of Pendragon, Pallas and Twelfth Night pulling short straws.
Part of the problem (I think) with these bands was that they were too focused on the sound of their inspiration (usually Genesis, Rush and Yes) so that they weren't actually progressive (with a small 'p'), they just had 'that sound'. Kind of a couple of steps away from being a covers band - and we've got more than our fair share of prog cover bands these days.
Personally, having been in primary school when the greats were doing the rounds, in the mid/late 80's in the UK these neo-prog bands were the best of a bad lot - we were deluged with rap, house, madchester and SAW - if you wanted to hear real music with actual musishinins, they were the lone voice in the wilderness (with some exceptions).
I'm not sure what Pendragon album you grabbed, but I did enjoy their first couple (The Jewel and 9:15 Live) - I've found their recent efforts to be insipid though, like Marillion's since Fish left. Just running out of ideas, I suspect. So I know where you're coming from.
Pallas went into hibernation through the 90's, but came back with a couple of ok albums - played last year's NEARFest (or was it the year before?) and had lots of glowing things to say about Mikey (as a musician and as a person). Their first full album ('The Sentinel') was pretty good - kind of like a heavier cousin of Tales From Topographic Oceans, but their most recent stuff is a bit 'by the book' and doesn't do it for me. Their biggest problem is their vocalist who's voice doesn't really suit the band.
My favourite forgotten gem from this era was 'Comedy of Errors' - one mini album showing great potential before giving in to playing covers and eventually just fading away...
It seems to me that somewhere in the late '70s, the arena-rock thing (Styx, Boston, REO, Journey) took off in America and somehow this stuff - which had the bombast of prog but little of the content - became an influence on both the existing prog bands and the ones soon to come. All these bands were good players who sometimes could whip out a cool tune, but overall were much less interesting and far more predictable. It's as if the British progressive music got mirrored in a really terrible way in America, then the British were stupid enough to pay attention to it.
Perfect example - put on Yes' 90125 and listen to Changes. That has a KILLER intro and outro, very cool, very effective, but it then slides into this godawful Forgeigner-esque POOT that makes up the bulk of the actual song. Trevor Rabin is a MASTER of melding excellent riffs onto soporific nonsense. I kinda almost admire him for it.
The British neo-prog bands strike me as having this kind of problem, but worse. The music has only the most superficial relationship to progressive music, and instead has the same kind of calculated pseudo-important Bic-lighter-waving harmonic and melodic content that the American arena-jizz bands did, but somehow are WORSE. I'd rather listen to fucking Styx. (Who at least had a FEW interesting moments early on.) It all seems to have this desparate need to be something it just isn't good enough to be. "Look at us! We're cool too, right?" No, you're a twerp with a DX-7 and the balls of an anemic roach.
The Pendragon album I heard was The World, which I was led to understand was one of their better efforts. I was reaching for beer to wash the taste of poo from my mouth. I heard some Pallas (don't remember which) a few years ago and thought pretty much the same thing. I remember hearing one of IQ's early albums and enjoying it more, but feeling no real reason to follow through - though to be fair, I heard one of their more recent (late '90s) albums, again, I can't remember the title, and thought it was pretty good.
I'm no purist, mind you, and I don't even mind a full-blown commercial pop influence on prog when it's done right - Supertramp is a good example of a pop band with prog overtones that did a lot of very good music, because they had a distinct personality and actual ideas, good melodies, and solid arrangements. The first few Alan Parsons Project albums are nice for that kind of thing too.
Hell, even the classic prog bands that went pop had a few good moments. I'd actually rather hear a couple of Genesis' singles than the watered-down half-assed extended stuff that passed for being "like the old stuff." (So, in the case of Invisible Touch, you got a couple terrible pop songs, a couple pretty good ones, a really interesting instrumental at the end, and a couple stupid overlong pieces of beer-commercial shit that delusional fans try to pretend is still prog. I only really picked that album because it's an obvious choice, I do still like a FEW things on it.) Yes kinda lost their minds, but there was usually at least some good detail in the arrangments and the occasional killer riff. (Something Genesis got really erratic about.) With Jethro Tull, I think they just got distracted a bit. Tull never really lost it for me. A bit of wasted time spent diddling with sequencers, but they didn't cheese out, and always kept their personality. They still have, too. The edge is long since gone away, but the basic character is intact, and they still find ways of challenging themselves. I see their early 80s stuff as a challenge that simply didn't come off more than anything else.
Then you get ELP, which more or less kept their personality intact, if in a less exciting way. But of course, Emerson lost his mind that one time and did that fucking "3" album, which is so fucking awful I still pull it out once in a while for a good laugh. I mean, if ya wanna go Spinal Tap, do it RIGHT, bitch. I actually LIKE "3" because it's FUNNY how bad it is. You can almost imagine a couple record execs feeding some terrible drug to Keith and saying "OK, make the Asia album that would embarras Geoff Downes himself" and sent Keith zombie-like into some Karloffian laboratory (Robert Berry sure as fuck qualifies as Renfield in this scenario, I think) where he pulled some levels and shriekd "It is alive!" The fact that only 3 people actually BOUGHT this stupid piece of shit makes it all the more hilarious to me.
The same kind of thing carries through to the '90s and into the present, because I "got" very few of the bands that led the prog-revival of that time. I enjoyed Dream Theater when they first came out, but too much of it strikes me as being filtered through that arena-bombast, as well as the 80s-shred stuff that also had its moments but usually was some asshole showing you how fast he could play his harmonic minor scales on top of G5 for days. Most of the other prog-metal bands of the 90s hit me the same way, but worse. I've got one Yngwie album, I don't need 50 clones, dammit.
There was a very interesting time in the late 80s/early 90s where, even though few people labelled it as "progressive", and the influence of the earlier prog bands was either under the surface or maybe not even there at all, I felt there was a few bands who even got their stuff on the radio regularly that did what *I* thought was truly interesting "progressive" music that had the true spirit of that music - creating an individual idenity and melding together disparate influences in interesting ways is more "progressive" to my ears than having a Mellotron, playing really fast, and having goofy lyrics about fairies and goblins.
So when I heard Faith No More and Living Colour and King's X in the late '80s, I thought "Shit, this is the new prog, and it doesn't even sound much like the old stuff." A couple years later I thought the same thing about Primus. I heard a striving for individual identity and some very cool ideas on Alice In Chains and Soundgardgen albums. None of these people sounded like the old prog stuff, but they had the qualities of that music that struck me the hardest. When I heard Radiohead I felt the same way. The Mars Volta is a good newer example. All these bands create something of their own out of other people's parts, and that's what I find interesting. Taking the surface bombast off old prog and melding it to half-baked harmonic and melodic ideas with a really uber-white rhythm section playing dumbed-down ideas in something other than 4/4 doesn't count to me, and that's why I can't take most of what passes for prog anymore. There's exceptions, but they're just that. A couple really excellent moments on a Spock's Beard album aren't enough to distract me from thinking "Well, the Gentle Giant ripoff section was really cool, but why did you have to follow it with THAT Journey-esque poo-chorus?"
The one band I'll still defend that is guilty of some of this shit but still has a lot of other things going for them is Rush. I've loved those guys for a long time and always will. They've danced pretty close to the edge of lighter-waving -music, operate on a lower level harmonically, some of their cooler rhythmic ideas are executed with the subtlety of a rabid baboon raping a kitten, and Peart's lyrics range from excellent to really fucking absurd, ("Net boy, net girl, send your impulse 'round the world, put your message in a modem,
and throw it in the Cyber Sea", are you fucking KIDDING me with this shit, monkeyboy? Jesus motherfucking CHRIST) but they've somehow always created a very distinct flavour and have never struck me as anything less than honest about what they do. The "prog" community tends to over-rate these guys to godlike status (I don't think you get to be "the world's greatest drummer" if you can't actually GROOVE a little), and most of their hardcore fans are uber-geeks on an insufferable level (I used to be one of these jerkoffs, so I think I can say that) but they still have the key ingredients and I still love those bacon-eating bastards a lot.
So now I think I'll go put on an AC/DC album or something. Christ, all this prog-talk has just added three or four months to my inability to get pussy.
Well, 'The World' is the point where Pendragon and I parted company. Didn't like it at all. I think they (and others) sort of developed into the bombastic side of things when they ran out of ideas.
I actually saw Rush and Pallas within a couple of weeks of each other back in 87 (or 88, maybe) - very disappointed with Rush (as a big Rush fan at the time) but blown away by Pallas. This may have had more to do with expectations than anything else, but that year I had just seen Tull's return to touring at the Cropredy festival, and was expecting great things of Rush, whilst Pallas took me by surprise - much more ballsy and unusual. I still listen to more Rush these days than Pallas (who really aren't in the same league).
As for Tull - I think they're resting on their laurels at the moment (and I'm not keen on the current infatuation with female violinists), but I did enjoy the 80's synth stuff - still some damn good songs on Under Wraps even though over-produced.
Got to agree on the current state of play - the good stuff is really not sounding like old-school prog, but has a life of its own, bringing in wildly varying influences and producing something which actually progresses rock music.
The Pallas appearance at NEARFest - which is what left the bad taste in my mouth, and yeah, a big part of that was the singer's histrionics as much or more than his voice - was in 2004. I told Mike (Keneally) at the time that his set - especially This Tastes Like A Hotel - was one of the few *genuinely progressive* things I saw that weekend. I like several of the other acts, and was blown away by Univers Zero - but it was obvious that a lot of prog has nothing progressive or new about it.
Mick, have you copped an earful of Sleepytime Gorilla Museum? They've been my frickin' art rock/RIO obsession for going on four years now. Others (that I've certainly exposed ArizonaBay to) that ding my bell include Alamaailman Vasarat (like what Tom Waits' band would sound like on a lot of speed), Hamster Theatre (to name a couple current/new ones), anything Fred Frith touches, and, seriously, just about any of the offshoots/relatives of the aforementioned Sleepytime Gorilla Museum: Two Foot Yard, Charming Hostess, Faun Fables (not so much prog as 18th-century goth-folk) and some Moe! Staiano performances.
All great recommendations of stuff that isn't much like old prog but is really excellent cutting-edge shit. SGM fuckin' rule, but you know that already. :)
SGM - yep, I've got a couple of their live shows from Dime, but haven't got round to anything official yet. I will. They are on my list of "things I'd like to receive on Birthday/Xmas/etc. if you can be bothered to take an interest in what I like and don't just buy me a pair of socks like you want to".
Not heard of ANY of the others apart from FF (who I have a couple of solo efforts from as well as various collaborations with Henry Kaiser), so off I go with Google in hand to seek out new music. Thanks da9ve!
Post a Comment