Counters
Free Counter Since April 24, 2008

Friday, May 30, 2008

Just watch the thing

http://www.ted.com/talks/view/id/229

Daddy loves Froggy. Froggy love Daddy?

Harvey Korman has left us at 81.

These are the kind of people I don't forget, who hit me over the head when I was a little kid and still make me laugh my ass off.

I'll miss him.

Love,
Arizona Bay

Thursday, May 29, 2008

New toon

http://tinyurl.com/2or43r

Written for J (or you can refer to the title for her first and middle initial) this afternoon when she made a joke that I should write her a song. Little does she know that if you catch me at the right time, I can actually do something good quickly. Not often, mind you. But I like this a lot. I have shitloads of these short little guitar vignettes around, I should record more of them.

Love,
Arizona Bay

Bambi Vs. The Highway Patrol

http://tinyurl.com/4a83cv


This is a part of the country where some cops think nothing of shooting unarmed black guys, but they couldn't get a fucking deer out of the way? Shit, you don't even have to actually shoot it. Pull out all your guns and fire off a bunch of warning shots, scaring the fuck out of it so it'll run off. Also quite an entertaining way to see how the general public waiting to get moving down the highway will react. Maybe if you'll scare it bad enough, it will ram right into someone's car and RID THE FUCKING HIGHWAY OF MORE MORE ASSHOLE IN TRAFFIC.

Not that I condone such behavior. I merely UNDERSTAND it.

Love,
Arizona Bay

Weird Fucking Psychocunts From Planet Hellstorm

My fucking neighbor tried to corner me again.

Her car's fucked, they have no money, they can't afford food, her back hurts, her boyfriend (I'd thought they were married, you mean that guy doesn't HAVE to be around this bitch and he does anyway?)needs new glasses, her nephew got somebody pregnant, her sister won't talk to her, and giant alien cockroaches are sending their own shit to her in the mail.

OK, I made up that last part. But, in that terrible monotone voice she has, EVERYTHING IS SHIT. She's the poster girl for entropy. You could listen to fifteen straight hours of Robert Smith from The Cure reading the obituaries of small children who were killed by their uncle after he ass-raped them in the toolshed, while lying face first in a pile of his own shit after his woman left him for Yul Brenner's corpse, and it wouldn't drive you to drink as fast as 7 seconds around this sociopath would.

Then she starts telling me that the scale at her doctor's is obviously wrong because it says she weighs ten pounds more than her scale does. OK.

"I was 244 pounds, and now I'm 222, but the doctor says I'm 232. But I've been on Slimfast since November 2006, and I know I'm losing weight.I drink two of those shakes a day."

OK, see, there's this thing called math. Even if your scale is right, you have lost 22 pounds. It's taken you A YEAR AND A HALF to do it. I don't care enough to check on how much the shit costs, but how the fuck much money have you spent drinking two of those shitty-tasting cups-'o-swill a day just to lose 22 pounds, especially since I see you outside WALKING every day, so you've HAD to have lost something just through exercise? Cunt, you got SCREWED. You want to lose 22 pounds in a year and a half, there's gotta be a better fucking way. May I suggest CUTTING YOUR OWN HEAD OFF.

I said it a hell of a lot more diplomatically than that, but she still got bitchy with me. Fuck it. Why bother? I walked back inside while she was still talking and locked the fucking door. Weird-ass cunt.

Love,
Arizona Bay

Heroes (Part 912)

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

Reason #10, 372,906 Why I Will Never Get Pussy On A Regular Basis For Any Extended Period Of Time

J called. It was very nice to hear from her, though I would like to have seen her as planned.

The bulk of our earliest converstation had to do with religion. She thinks I'm interesting, which is nice since most people think I'm an asshole. It's why I love you people reading this - you guys LIKE my bullshit.

So she began asking me questions to which I can only give long elaborate answers to, because, kids, I'm programmed to be a long-winded prick. I'm actually better at this than I was ten years ago, the time I first went online. A couple of you know me from back then and can attest that I am in fact more coherent and concise than I USED to be. Scary thought, that.

But I rambled on and on and she kept making observations and asking questions that allowed me to go on and on, though I was trying to let her get a word in too. I'm not always good at that, most of you know that too. But I'm fucking TRYING.

In the end though, it occurred to me when we said goodbye that even though I try really hard to make sure people know that I do NOT consider myself any kind of authority on anything, that I hope like all fuck that people consider the evidence of what I have to say but do NOT put stock in ANYTHING I say without checking it out their self, and that while I pretty much live by Kurt Vonnegut's statement that "You understand, of course, that everything I say is horseshit" in the end, I just come off like a rambling asshole. One of a certain intelligence and insight, I hope. But pretty much...a rambling asshole.

Women don't want that. You are supposed to let THEM be the center of the fucking universe. A few of them will fuck you even if they think of you as an asshole, but only a few, and it will never last. The odds of that are similar to the odds of Jesus Fuckin' Christ showing up tomorrow to take all you fucking Left Behind readers back Home.

Plenty of excellent good-hearted women admire my efforts. Few of them are stupid enough to fuck me. We always end up "just friends", and I'm gratful for their friendship, but if just ONE of them would suck my cock too, that would make the effort that much easier to endure. Hell, I might even be BETTER at it with a good suckjob or twelve to kickstart my day. And I ALWAYS return the favor, girls. You know that by now.

I will die alone and afraid in a pool of my own shit. But I will do so having EARNED that distinguished end (come on, do you really think dying in a fucking hospital after six months of being fed through a tube is BETTER?) and I can think of no way better to earn it than to keep on being the asshole I am. I'm four cans of sin into the night and I haven't shaved in four days, so I'm utterly unfuckable, but goddammit I have IDEAS. Shitty ideas of no worth to the cosmos as a whole perhaps, but ideas do more for this tiny little ball in the void than having a really big cock do. You don't get blown as much, but you do get REMEMBERED more. Unless you're John Holmes. then this entire theory gets thrown out the window. Goddammit.

Or maybe I'm just full of shit. Oh well. Crack open another crappy beer, kids. Let Grandpa Bay tell you a tale or two.

Love,
Arizona Bay

Two things, one really short, one really long

And the short one has to do with my penis. Go figure.

1.) J let me know late last night that there were conflicts that meant tonight's date has been called off. My initial inner response to this was cynical, but I've yet to have any reason to worry. This time I'll accept her word on it. But given the lessons of Danielle, I ain't holding my breath too damn long this time.

2.) What follows is the un-proofread first draft of a very long article on the New Testament resurrection stories and the place of Mary Magdalene within them. It needs editing and more content on Mary herself, sparked as it was by a TV special on her within the context of the impact of Dan Brown's Da Vinci Code, which I'm looking forward to reading again. If I seem a bit hard on him in what you read below, it's not because I dislike his book (I happened to love it) but because I find it annoying that someone who's only credentials are that of a novelist can have his extremely questionable views on actual history taken seriously by journalists, religious leaders, and the general public. I like his book. His need to defend the shoddy pseudo-history in it as being truthful bugs me. Hey, I'm just an amateur asshole too. That's why I'm on the internet and not on fucking TV. But in the end, it's hardly Dan Brown that is as irritating as the people who think that the BIBLE is actual history and who are still hammering it down people's heads. That's the thing I'm most interested in.

Anyway, this is only gonna be up for a short time. Copy it to a file if you like. This first version is for you, my friends.

-------------------

A few years back, after the shitstorm of public attention given Dan Brown's novel The Da Vinci Code, ABC anchor (and ungodly hot uber-MILF, I'd gladly wear her like a feed bag) Elizabeth Vargas hosted a special called "Unlocking Da Vinci's Code," I've seen it a couple times, and it was just re-run on National Geographic, so I made coffee and spent a couple hours in front of the TV.

There's all sorts of things that can be said about the special and about Dan Brown's book. I highly enjoyed The Da Vinci Code, and like many people, it sparked an interest in this kind of religious history for me. I'd say it had a huge impact on my desire to research this stuff.

But one of the unfortunate aspects of the novel's mass appeal is that while there would otherwise be no reason to attach historical credibility to something presented as a work of fiction, Dan Brown has a habit of showing up to defend the history in his book as accurate. So you end up with things like this ABC special, which, to its credit, pretty much shoots down the vast majority of Brown's historical claims (and similar ones by others) as little better than speculation. His approach to history seems to be "if it might have happened, it probably did." Which is about as far removed from actual historical methods as you can get. He's a very fine story-teller, but a pretty piss-poor excuse for any kind of historical information.

The over-arching theme of his book, however, is certainly true - the group of Christians that became the orthodox church did so only by minimizing and repressing the views of other groups. This is very clear to historians, huge amounts of evidence attest to that.

The other theme - that Jesus and Mary Magdalene got hitched and had kids and their descendants became French royalty, holy blood, holy grail, yadda yadda, is familiar by now to most people who are not living in un-lighted caves. This has sparked a renewed interest in the historicity (or lack thereof) of Mary Magdalene and her place in Christianity.

At the conlusion of the special, Vargas (have I mentioned I'd worship her pussy in a heartbeat) states that while most of hte claims of The Da Vinci Code cannot be verified, we have learned a lot more about the relationship between Jesus and Mary.

Unfortunately, that isn't true either.

There are a lot of points that can be made here, but I want to make the one obvious one, and then focus on the one aspect of Mary's story that seems so important to even the most liberal religious folk, such as some of the people who show up in the special. This isn't intended to piss on them, many of them made very good points and are certainly both far more informed than Dan Brown, and far more open-minded than the kind of religious followers who would go apeshit over a novel and try to make Brown out to be some kind of evil force. I'm just interested in looking at facts, what CAN be said about Mary Magdalene.

Not a fuck of a lot, kids.

The obvious point is this - there is incredibly little to go on within the sources we have. Much of what the story of Mary is based on comes from sources well over a hundred (in some cases nearly 400) years after the events they supposedly describe, and these sources are so filled with obvious legend and inflation as to be virtually useless to historians looking for information on either Mary or Jesus. These are the "Gnostic Gospels" you hear so much about in these discussions today, the ones discovered in 1948 in Egypt. This was brought up in the special, though guests such as Elaine Pagels (who certainly can be considered an authority on the subject, she wrote the first popular discussion of these "gospels") try to attach more significance to them than I can see as logical. It is simply not good history to take seriously stories from centuries after the supposed fact.

Which leaves us with the sources closer to the time. Like it or not, the four gospels of the New Testament are the best sources we have. The letters of Paul were written earlier, but there is so very little information about the actual life of Jesus within Paul's work as to make them irrelavent to this topic. Other sources, pagan or Jewish, from closer to the supposed time of Jesus, are also of incredibly little help.

So, let's look at Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.

These books were in fact still written decades after, and are full of conflicting stories, inaccurate history, reliance on outside myth, and outright nonsense. It's extremely tempting to write them off entirely as well, because after spending time with these writings, you can only come away skeptical. Some scholars find bits and pieces of things they consider worth pursuing as actual history, but nobody short of someone injecting "faith" into their reading takes seriously the vast majority of what is in these four books. The scholars who do find those bits and pieces are very strong authorities on the topic, to be sure, and their theories are not without merit, but it seems to me that they feel the need to salvage SOMETHING from these works and do not in fact need to. I'd suggest these books are completely unreliable as history.

But let's look at them anyway, and show WHY, and do so in the context of the story of Mary Magdalene.

The contention of many who ascribe significance to Mary is that her presence in the resurrection story as the key witness to the empty tomb is what makes her so important. Let's ignore the obvious point - the inherent absurdity of a resurrection of the dead after three days - and take a closer look at the story.

There are in fact four stories, none of them agreeing with the others. It is clear to nearly all scholars that Mark's gospel was written first. The most obvious evidence for this is that Matthew and Luke copy huge amounts of Mark nearly verbatim in their own works. (We're using the names given to these works just for the sake of convinience. They are all anonymous and the names were attached to them much later by church leaders.) There are interesting and amusing examples of Matthew and Luke altering bits of Mark either to correct his ignorance of Judaism or to make a theological point that he doesn't, but the reliance on Mark is clear. John's gospel seems to be removed from the other three (though you can find bits of them within John) and the overall tone of John and the obvious inflation of certain stories that happens from Mark's through Luke and Matthew and then into John leaves very few current opinions that John was not written after the other three.

So, what is Mark's story - the first we have - of the death and resurrection of Jesus?

Mary Magdalene (and another Mary) are said to be witnesses at Jesus' crucifixion, and to have "looking on" when Joseph of Arimathea (insert Python joke here) rolled the stone across the tomb after securing Jesus' body from Pilate.

These two women are then said to show up after sunrise the day after Sabbath to find the stone rolled away, and a "young man" in a white robe sitting on the stone. He informs them that Jesus isn't there, he is risen. He tells them to tell the "disciples and Peter" that Jesus is going ahead of them to Galilee, and they will see him there.

So what do the women do? They freak out and run away and tell nobody because "they were afraid."

And that's IT in the book of Mark.

Hey, wait a minute, dude. You stopped at Mark 16:8. Doesn't that last chapter of Mark have TWENTY verses?

Not in any of the earliest and best manuscripts we have of Mark, it doesn't.

Mark 16:9-20 do no appear in these manuscripts. Verse 9 also starts very abruptly in contrast to how verse 8 ends, then immediately contradicts verse 8 by saying Mary went and told the disciples what she had seen.

Mark 16:9-20 cannot be used as history. And only the evangelical/fundamentalist scholars would suggest otherwise.

So that's what we have. Two women, one of them Mary Magdalene, are supposed witnesses to there not being anyone in the tomb. And they tell nobody.

This has created a major problem for many students of the New Testament, accustomed as they are to the other three stories. This appears odd to them. Why would Mark end his story this way? It's a very stark ending. Surely there must be more?

But in his book The Incredible Shrinking Son Of Man, Robet M. Price makes a point that needs to be considered. Knowing what else we know about the vast reliance on pagan myth in the construction of the Jesus myth, it's not odd at all to see Mark end this way. (He also makes the point that Mark's story has a flaw in that the Middle Eastern climate pretty much makes useless the efforts of the two women to anoint the body for preservation two days after death. Perhaps earlier, pre-Mark stories we do not have did not have the observance of the Sabbath prolonging their trip to the tomb, but that is of course speculation.)

Note that in Mark's tale, Jesus does not appear to anyone after the resurrection. The women see a "young man" who tells them to tell the others, and they do not. It would appear that in Mark's time, there were no stories of post-resurrection Jesus appearances. Looking through Matthew and Luke (as we will soon do) it is obvious that they simply made these stories up, since they do not appear in Mark, their primary source.

Price makes the point that the stark ending of Mark, with no appearances to anyone after Jesus is risen, is completely consistent with many other legends of people who supposedly cheated death. Within the Old Testament and later commentary on it you find Enoch, Moses, and Elijah all disappearing with no one finding their body. In pagan mythology, you find this same story told of Heracles, Aristaeus, Aenus, Romulus, Empedocles, and Apollonius of Tyana. Simply, no one could find the body, so they assumed the person had been translated into heaven. Mark's story, written in this context, would not have appeared nearly as strange to his intended audience as it does to us. There was no NEED for Jesus to appear after his death. The empty tomb told the story well enough.

The argument has been made that the later stories of Christ appearing are simply filling out the details, that Mark only doesn't have these, but the others do, bringing us "the rest of the story." But this seems very unlikely. A key point in studying history is that when you have multiple tales of the same event, the least spectacular is the one you have to go with. If there were in fact more details, stories of post-resurrection appearances, what possible reason would Mark have had to not include them? They certainly exist only to further add weight to the entire story, and if Mark had access to them, there is no reason to assume he wouldn't have made use of them. It can only be deduced that he did not, and that his story was sufficient for him, since that's what he had to work with.

Looking at Luke and Matthew, it becomes apparent quickly that their stories are not merely added onto Mark's, but that they had to CHANGE Mark's story in order to make their points. They begin with Mark, but the details are warped into another shape.

Luke's story has interesting additions to Mark's story Joseph or Arimathea putting the body of Jesus into the tomb, though it is clearly based on Mark's. He says Joseph "had not consented to their plan and action" and he adds the detail that the tomb had not been used for anyone else before Jesus. Otherwise, it's the same story. As for the women witnessing the burial of Jesus, it is the same as Mark except for the detail that the women are NOT mentioned by name at this point in Luke's story. Also they are just "the women" through the next part of the story - the events at the empty tomb - and are finally mentioned by name only once they go off to tell the disciples, something they did NOT do in Mark. And notice who these women are. In Mark it was the two women named Mary. In Luke, it is them, and it is also Joanna, and "also the other women with them", clearly inflating Mark's story with more witnesses. The Christian apologist tends to say that perhaps Mark only mentioned the two and the others were there also, but this argument is weak. One cannot assume Mark knew of other women there if he does not mention them, the fact that he does not SAY there are more therefore cannot in anyway lead one to think he knew there was. And why would he not mention them? What purpose wpud that serve? Just because the other women could have been there when factoring Luke's account does not mean that they were. There is no logic to that argument. Again, the story with the additional details is highly suspect, and Mark's earlier account is shown to have been inflated by Luke.

Back to the tomb, there is another problem.

In Luke, the story goes like this: They come to the tomb at early dawn and find the stone rolled away. They enter the tomb and do not find the body. Suddenly two men stand before them in "dazzling clothing" and the women are terrified, bowing before the men. The men say to them that Jesus is risen. They tell them to remember how he spoke to them while He was still in Galilee, that the Son of Man must be delivered into the hands of sinful men, and be crucified, and on the third day rise again. The women remember these words, then they run home and report "all these things to the eleven and to all the rest."

Hmm, not exactly Mark's story, though a couple details are clearly derived from it. (And remember, large parts of Luke's gospel are clearly derived from Mark as they quote verbatim from it. Sometimes small details are altered, and sometimes, as in here, things are changed much more drastically. All in a clear attempt to make a point not present within Mark.)

In Mark, the two women are said to show up after sunrise, in Luke it is "early dawn." Not a real problem, but hang onto that thought. We're coming back to it later.

In Mark, they find the stone rolled away, and the "young man" in a white robe sitting on the stone. In Luke there are two men, and the women have to ENTER the tomb. Does Mark simply leave out this detail? There is no way of knowing, no matter how the apologist tries to make the two fit. It simply is not stated in Mark.

The men are standing next to them, not sitting on the stone. Whatever difference may exist between a "white robe" and "dazzling clothing", Luke's account is obviously making a bigger statement about their apparel than Mark, a subtle but noticable inflation.

Then, instead of Mark's simpler statement of the young man that Jesus is risen and they are to tell the disciples to go find him in Galilee, Luke turns the message (of two instead of one) into a more elaborate one, essentially telling them women they should have known to expect the empty tomb since Jesus had told them way back in Galilee he would rise again. Why is this not in Mark? Did he simply forget? It is difficult to see how this could not have been in his story if he knew of it. Logic dictates that Luke is making a further theological point by inflating the account in Mark that did not do enough to make Luke's point for him.

Of course, Mark says the women told nobody. This makes everyting that happens after this point in Luke fall apart, if in fact Mark is right. If he's wrong...uh, he's wrong. This presents an insurmountable problem for anyone looking to harmonize these two accounts. One of them must be wrong. Given the amount of reliance Luke has on Mark's work and his obvious inflations and more developed theology, it is not logical to assume Luke wins this contest.

After the story of the women telling the disciples and "all the rest", Luke goes on with appearances of Jesus to his followers. Note that the name Mary Magdalene is not present from this point onwards in Luke. She was simply the first of three woman mentioned by name in a larger group. One can draw conclusions about her importance from this, but one has to pull these conclusions from thin air. Nothing can be said about Mary in this context except that she was there, and perhaps considered the primary witness since her name is mentioned first. This is ALL that can be logically drawn from the account. All else is speculation.

Now we turn to Matthew, also a book that used Mark as a primary source.

Thus far we've only concerned ourselves with what happened with Jesus from the time his body was claimed by Joseph of Arimathea onwards. This is still the focus, but it should be noted that in Matthew, there are details just before this that are amusing additions to what we find in Mark and Mattthew. An earthquake strong enough that "the rocks were split" rattles the area, and many dead come from their graves and go into the city and appear to the living. You'd think an event like this would have made local news, but alas, this is the only mention we have of it anywhere. The first century CE is NOT a poorly documented era in this part of the world. There are enough Roman and Jewish contributions to history at this time to make one wonder about events in the New Testament that appear nowhere else. As if the "slaughter of the innocents" under Herod and the bizarre empire-wide census mentioned by Luke are not enough, Matthew adds on a Stephen King-like tale of earthquakes and zombies. It's enough to make one sympathetic with those who choose to chuck the entire gospel tradition into the wastebin because of this kind of nonsense, but for now, I find it more entertaining and informative to pursue the course of taking these stories apart in detail.

Back to our main theme, we find in Matthew the same essential story of Joseph of Arimathea to be found in the others. He's said here to be a "rich man" instead of part of the local council as it's said in Mark and Luke, but that's a minor detail, As in Mark, Matthew has the two women named Mary watching on.

But then Matthew adds another detail not found in Mark and Luke. He says that the chief priests and the Pharisees (a detailed description of anti-Jewish and anti-Pharisee elements in the New Testament would be helpful at this point in showing why this is added, but it's beyond the scope of the present anaylsis( go to Pilate and say that he should dispatch a guard to the tomb since the followers of Jesus could steal the body and claim he has risen. Then Pilate gives them that guard, and they also put a seal on the stone.

Again, using the principle of questioning the inflation of stories, this seems strange to be mentioned in Matthew but not Mark or Luke, who surely could have used it to bolster their own accounts. As Robert M. Price has argued, there are parallels with Matthew's creation and the stories in the book of Daniel of the three men thrown into the fiery furnace and Daniel in the lion's den. Notably, in Daniel 6:17, the king has a stone rolled in front of the lion's den and a seal placed on it. There are numerous examples within the gospels of stories being reworked from the Old Testament, this is only a more obvious one. Apologists like to make claims about "prophecy" and God making these parallels happen Himself (what a clever and playful deity!) but these claims cannot be taken seriousy by historians without evidence. The extent to which the gospel writers sourced their tales on both pagan myth and re-written Old Testament stories is too great to fall back on such weak logic.

Matthew 28 begins with the women coming to the tomb "as it began to dawn." (note the subtle re-wording from the time mentioned in the previous accounts.) This time we are back to Mark's account, because it is once again the two Marys, mentioned by name. No other women are mentioned. So again, the inflation within Luke is highly suspect.

We are also treated to the women being spoken to by one person, not two. But this time, whereas in Mark it is a "young man" sitting on the stone, and in Luke two men appearing in the tomb, Matthew has "an angel of the Lord" descend from Heaven to roll away the stone and sit on it. It's not difficult to see that Mark and Luke simply imply that their men are angels instead of saying it outright, therefore no real conflict there. But it's interesting that only Luke's has the women actually enter the tomb, and that Matthew has the angel "descend" instead of simply being there as in Mark. These are very small details in the final analysis, but they are evident, and show the influence of what clearly happens when oral traditions are used to pass on information later put into textual form.

The angel, by the way, is said to be in clothing white as snow with the appearance of lightning. Nice touch from Matthew, more inflation that would make for good Hollywood effects.

The message the angel has for the Marys is almost identical to Mark's, with only one small addition, that He is risen, "just as He said." Like Luke, the implication is that the women should have known what they were in for. Dumb chicks! God SAID you were only half as worthwhile as men! Get it together! Luke does this in a far less flowery way than Luke, and gets his point across with the "just as He said" that does not appear in Mark.

The post-resurrection appearance of Jesus is significantly shorter than in Luke's, and has different details. Read this on your own for further amusement, we are not as concerned at this time with these stories since they are obvious additions to Mark.

But there is one thing to further discuss, the guards that Matthew adds to the tomb. When the angel appears, the guards shake in fear and become "like dead men." Then after the angel and the women leave, the guards go back to the chief priests and tell them what happened. The priests give them money to shut the fuck up and only say that the disciples came and stole the body, and that if any of this comes to the governor's attention, they'll save the guards' asses for them. And they do so and the story became known among the Jews, "and is to this day." An amusing detail further showing the relatively long amount of time between the occurrence and Matthew's report.

Does this make any sense? What use is the story of the guards if they were "like dead men" at the time? They're supposed to say disciples came and stole the body and they weren't even awake to see it? And the Jewish leaders hear about the angel but are in no way moved by it? This story is just silly, and coming as it does only in Matthew, can best be seen as a fabrication added onto the Markan account, an account Matthew had to change in order to put the story into place. It cannot be accepted as historical.

The Gospel Of John has long been noted to have significant differences to the Synoptics (the name given the other three since they are obviously related through Mark's original account.) One major difference between Mark and John is that Mark has Jesus repeatedly tell followers and miracle-recipients not to tell anyone who he is. Whereas in John, Jesus spends the vast majority of his time telling everyone who he is. This is comical to note, and Matthew and Luke come in the middle of these extremes, showing a clear progression from Mark into making Jesus into an increasingly more God-like figure.

But let's look again at what happens once Jesus is dead. In John, the story changes right away. The other three accounts essentially agree on who Joseph of Arimathea was and what he did. Not John.

Joseph is not presented as a local council member or simply as "a rich man", but as a secret disciple of Jesus. Now just a follower, but a disciple, and one who kept his identity secret "for fear of the Jews." This is fairly bizarre in itself. Before he was a member of the Council. If this is so, what Jews were he afraid of? The ones he spent all his time around? HIMSELF?? John repeatedly says "the Jews" in an over-arching and derogatory manner. It's concievable that a council member became a follower of Jesus, but all this secret superspy bullshit smacks of John's constant efforts to denigrate Jews in the name of...uh...a dead Jew. This is nowhere to be found in the other three gospels, probably becauce, even with their own progressive anti-Jewish sentiments, they just didn't go as far as John to make the point that Jews were vicious bastards. There is much that can be written about the invention of anti-Semitism within the New Testament, but John's gospel takes the cake (presumably a leavened one), and this is a fine example.

But John adds (and subtracts) more detail than even this. In the other three, Joseph acts alone, with the women merely watching. After Joseph is given the body of Jesus by Pilate (this detail doesn't change among the four accounts, but it's interesting to note that Joseph seems less afraid of the Roman prefect than he is of "the Jews", even though Pilate is the only one around with the authority to execute people) Joseph is joined by another man. Nicodemus, a character that appears earlier in John but in no other gospel comes along. For what purpose? He brings the spices to preserve the body.

Interesting. In the other three accounts, the job of preserving the body falls to the women, who have to wait until after the Sabbath, which means they are a couple days late in getting to this task, after which decay would already have begun. In John, the "Jewish day of preparation" was coming but the body was prepared beforehand by Joseph and Nicodemus. Note that it's phrased "the Jewish day of preparation." Of COURSE it was Jewish, THESE PEOPLE WERE JEWS. Can you see the obvious need of a writer long after the event to tailor his story for an audience that was having heated arguments over Gentile/Jewish affairs? Again, this is a topic that figures heavily in the writing of the New Testament, but is beyond the scope of this article.

The women are not there for this. They no longer have the same role they had in the previous three accounts. Additionally, John says that the new tomb in which no one had been laid (note the parallel to other non-Markan accounts) was in a garden. No mention of a garden elsewhere. Not a major point, but an interesting small addition that comes nowhere else. But again, the change of dropping the women out of the story so far is what is even more interesting.

But they are not totally absent. Well, Mary Magdalene isn't. John chapter 20 starts by bringing Mary into the mix. This time she is alone. No other women. Could it be that the others are simply not mentioned? Why? The absence of others in this account does not logically lead to them simply not being mentioned because three other rather different accounts DO mention them. It is possible, but it is not logically admissible.

Mary comes to the tomb, apparently just for a visit since the body has been prepared this time. When does she come? John says early in the day, "while it was still dark." Uh, doesn't the other three say it WASN'T still dark? Mark says it outright, that the sun was up. Matthew and Mark make it vaguer placing it at dawn. But it is unambiguous here in John - he states it was still dark.

Then the story takes on a real turn in comparion to the Synoptics. Mary comes to the tomb and sees the stone has been removed. Already we have a problem, given that in one other story there's an angel coming down and doing it in front of her, that detail not in this version. But what happens next? After she sees the stone is gone, she runs off to get Simon Peter. No message from angels at this point, not even Mary taking the time to check for a body, nothing at all but a stone rolled away, and off runs Mary. What the fuck? John diverts the flow of the story drastically now, keeping some details but making the events come out quite different.

There is something in this account that is interesting in the context of finding out more about who Mary Magdalene was, and the claims made about her in modern times. She is certainly a key figure in the resurrection story since she is the only consistent detail in who shows up at the tomb first. But the desire of fiction writers such as Dan Brown, and of otherwise more credible scholars such as Karen Armstrong and others to add further importance to Mary has to be done so at the expense of the John account. In fact, there is so little said about her in the other three that all of these efforts seem more than a little silly, but John's account can in no way be used to make Mary Magdalene look to be quite the pillar of the early church that she is sometimes made out to be, certainly not one on the level of the other disciples. And any suggestion that she was an intimate companion of Jesus, let alone his wife, seems altogether fiction. Let's look at the reasons why as we dissect John's resurrection tale further.

First, consider what we already know. Mary runs off to find Simon Peter, which implies his authority over the other disciples. Also there is, "the disciple whom Jesus loved", whatever that may mean. (No small speculation has been offered on this person, but that's not part of the current discussion.) Then consider what she says, "They have taken away the Lord out of the tomb, and we do not know where they have laid Him." The use of "we" in this context does admittedly cast the lack of other named women in another light, but it's hardly conclusive of much.

But - and we're close to coming to John's own mention of this - if as the other gospels say, and if one assumes that Mary is a close confident of Jesus as the current modern crop of Magdalene-admirers would have you believe, wouldn't she have known better than this? It seems extremely thick, if not downright stupid, for someone who has spent all this time around someone who supposedly said he was to be risen (another topic for discussion in another time, there is in fact much reason to think of that as another invention that was inflated as time went along) to not even consider that option. To not even look into the tomb itself, but to run off assuming someone has stolen the body. Perhaps she was hanging around Roman guards in emply of shadowy Jewish leaders. Too bad John doesn't have that part of the story.

So now, in John and not the others, Peter and the un-named disciple have a track meet to see who can get there first. The other disciple gets there first but Peter goes inside first. Then the other enters. They take turns noticing the grave-cloths. These details serve no real purpose and are clearly invented. And then, in another example of disciple-thickness, John says "For as yet they did not understand the Scripture, the He must rise again from the dead." There are various depictions of Jesus' disciples just not "getting it", even as there are also conflicting stories of what exactly he told them about himself. The whole thing (yes, another article beyond this one) is fraught with incohereny and serves mostly just to make Jesus' disciples look like a helpless crew of unenlightened dumbasses. Who then go on to change the world. Odd little thing this New Testament, ain't it?

Then we're back to Mary, who stands outside and cries, then finally she looks into the tomb. About time. And THEN she sees two angels. Not one. Two, Not just men. Angels. They are dressed in white. Apparently John doesn't feel inclined to put bright country-star sequins on their clothing like in Luke or make them into lightning superheroes like in Matthew. His story is fantastic enough without those minor-yet-silly additions.

This time they're not sitting on a stone or just standing there, but sitting where the body of Jesus had been, one at the head and one at the feet. Nice narrative twist, completely at odds with the other three. Maybe the one guy kept splitting in two and back like some weird ameoba, and changed positions a lot. A shape-shifting, position-relocating messenger from God would at this point make the story no less historical than it already has shaped up to be thus far.

They ask her why she's crying. She replies, "Because they have taken away my Lord, and I do not know where they have laid Him." Wow. If Dan Brown is right, Jesus sure didn't pick his bride based on her brains. The body is gone, angels are there. And still she's ready to file a missing-corpse complaint with...who, exactly?

She says this to the angels, then turns around and there is Jesus, though she DOESN'T RECOGNIZE HIM. Mary Magdalene seems to be a very unlikely candidate for sainthood. Or perhaps she's that much in shock. Possibly, but it certainly seems a woman who was only one of many followers, albeit of a somewhat closer status, is more likely to be that far gone and unable the recognize the dead guy she's so intent on finding than a woman married him and who had his kid. Insert one's own joke about Jesus-copulation here.

Jesus asks her who she's looking for and why she's crying. I guess that's more fun than saying "Hey, it's me. Take a friggin' look already."

Then, in what must be John's bizarre anti-Semitic sense of vicious irony, Mary assumes this guy who can't possibly be Jesus to her yet is the gardener. Is this INTENTIONAL comedy? Well, he just had to add in that this was all happening in a garden, I suppose you should add a gardener. The entire thing is not unlike the scene in the Pink Panther movie where Clouseau thinks the gardener is a bee-keeper. Perhaps Mary had just been working out in an upstairs private gym and accidentally fell down a flight of stairs, rendering her unable to recognize her friends. It's a possibility every bit as worthy of mention as the implausable scenario we have here, cooked up solely by John.

She assumes he's the gardener and tells him that if he's taken the body of Jesus away, let her know where he is. As if a grave-robbing gardener is going to pass on that information to the deceased's wife/traveling companion/vague acquaintance.

Finally, Jesus himself performs a miracle and puts an end to this protracted nonsense by saying her name. I suppose "Mary" actually translates to "Wake up and smell the coffee, you delusional twit." She exclaims to him "Rabboni!", which for some reason John has to mention is Hebrew for "teacher."

Again, this seems to be more an encounter between a (cough, cough) risen Lord and a rather clueless follower than it does, as Dan Brown and friends would have you believe, a woman with intimate secret knowledge and even soon-to-be marital relations of said Lord. Perhaps they got married later, but even a prospective girlfriend who'd been close enough for inclusion in an inner circle of some kind is less likely to refer to him as "teacher" than by his name, or perhaps as the fictional wife in Sam Kinison's standup might put it, "Where have YOU been with those twelve fucking losers who won't get a job, Mr. Savior?" Women are seldom treated particularly well in the Bible, but it's not often a man goes out of his way to make a woman look as blitheringly idiotic as John does Mary. Even the wrong-headed efforts of the Catholic church centuries later to turn Mary Magdalene into a prostitute (based on a clearly misguided reading of another part of John's account) has Mary coming out looking better than she does here. The other disciples surely are thick, but Mary - being worth half as much as one man, if the Old Testament is to be believed - is just a fuckin' retard, dude.

Jesus then says "Stop clinging to me" which sure sounds like something you'd say to a spouse, so maybe there's somethng to this DaVinci Code bullshit after all. But the entire quote reads, "Stop clinging to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father, but go to my Bretheren and say to them, 'I ascend to My Father and your Father, and My God and your God.'" And she does do. Great, the vessel of Christ's bloodline is now, after all this, reduced to the role of secretary, dispensing messages to the men. And rather overly poetic messages at that. Sounds a bit like the meandering company proclamations of a modern corporation being passed around the office by the CEO's ditzy got-the-job-through-nepotism daughter to me.

In all seriousness, stripping away the foray into making more light of John's resurrection account than it already deserves, this entire episode is so full of obvious fiction as to be useless as a source of inspiration. Looking at where we've been so far, putting John's version into the broader context, it simply does not hold up either to those interested in historical accuracy, or to those looking for Mary Magdalene as an exalted church leader.

Of course, following Mary's message to the disciples, we are again treated to stories of Jesus coming to them, stories exclusive to John which seem intended to make theological statements the other three did not make. And in the case of Mark, that wasn't even attempted to be made in this manner.

We have deconstructed only a small part of the Christ Myth. Even the events immediately leading up to the ones discussed here - Jesus' arrest, trial, and crucifixion - are handled differently in each gospel. The amount of borrowings, blurring of details, and outright fabrication involved in the four gospels of the New Testament, not to mention the further distortion over centuries of botched copying by ham-handed scribes (many not of the professional variety) displaying either incompetence or intentional changing of the texts to fit them into someone's view of later theological disputes, are subjects about which much has been and will continue to be written. This article is only the tip of the iceberg. I'd encourage anyone reading this who has the interest to continue in this kind of research to seek out the work of biblical scholars of far more stature than I as a rock musician with an amateur interest in the subject can possibly aspire to at the moment. These are very well-educated people who do not always agree on every detail, but who, as I've tried to do here, have applied a strict historical method to studing the New Testament and have come to the conclusion that much of it is not historially accurate. A few - and I'm coming to count myself as one stumbling along behind these scholars - consider NONE of the gospel record to be historical. Find that out for yourself if you are so inclined. You certainly don't have to take my word for it. But I'd suggest also being extremely skeptical of novelists who cling to unfounded historical claims, and of scholars who are desparate to salvage a historical Jesus out of the multi-layered flung-together scrapheap that is the New Testament.

Love,
Arizona Bay

Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Virgin-Birth Control

Eat Shit & Die, Jewboy

"And thou shalt eat it as barley cakes, and thou shalt bake it with dung that cometh out of man, in their sight." - Ezekiel 4:12


"Dung that cometh out of man."

No poetic skill can change the message, kids - God told somebody to make bread with THEIR OWN SHIT. And he added "in their sight", which pretty much says, "Go do it on Fear Factor."

You know, I'm starting to think Jews ARE evil.

Love,
Arizona Bay

Of Bears & Foreskins




I LOVE that pic. Here's where I stole it from. When ya look at it, God pretty much is the Jewish Rambo on some really fuckin' major steroids...1

http://tinyurl.com/32c2qo

Love,
Arizona Bay

Monday, May 26, 2008

Bzzzzzzzzzz

Talked to this new lady for a long time on the phone. Hit some "intriguing" conversation. (No, not phone-fucking, but certainly on-topic.) Yet she seems to be very sharp and cool and nice and has her shit mostly together.

We're going out Wednesday.

Holy shit,
Arizona Bay
--------
Talked to her again. The very sound of her voice does things to me. Nice things. Well, OK, it makes me turn into Wood-Boy too, but it's NICE Wood-Boy. The guy that wants to be the best fucking disgusting male pig he can possibly be so as to win her heart, capture her soul, and...uh...munch on her furbox for a very long time.

Scary shit. And I really like it. I need to go dump ice on my head now. Christ, I haven't even MET this girl for real yet.

Sunday, May 25, 2008

Wake You Up Before Me Blow Joe

I stuck that damn cheesy hook from that Wham song into EVERYTHING last night. It made me fuck up the bass line in the middle of All Right Now since it didn't really fit and I suddenly forgot how to play a fucking bass part I've played for twenty damn years.

There is a very large bouncer at this place, big hairy guy nicknamed after a large animal you hunt for in the wilderness. And a really nice guy. He's been bugging us to do Tainted Love by Soft Cell. So we debuted that last night. For some reason that song has always suggested leather-clad gay sex to me, but I actually enjoy playing it.

I was hacking and coughing like all fuck, still can't shake this cold. But I managed to whip out a couple of my better guitar solos. Didn't go "out" at all, just nailed down the best combination of taste and aggression I've done in a while. On bass, I was mostly laid back and in the groove. Though I made more dumbass mistakes in the first set than I usually do in three gigs.

Two very loud women yelling at us. They kept wanting Mellencamp. Despite the fact that we'd played the two songs of his we do. They WOULDN'T SHUT UP. This went on for almost two sets. At one point I got into the mic and said "Yeah, I remember my first 67 beers..."

The chickens were mighty helpful. And during Wipeout I threw paper airplanes around. None of them flew worth a damn.

I got to talk for the first time on the phone last night to a very nice lady I met online recently. Just friendly at the moment, but I rather like her.

Busy day ahead. Week-late birthday party for my kiddo (who is so cool, I woke up and was walking down the hall and she came running at me, "Daddy! Daddy!" and gave me a big hug, gawd, I'm a lucky fuckin' guy) then I'm taking her over to play with the daughter of my flute-playing friend, then I'm dropping genealogy notes to a distant cousin I never talked to until last week.

I need more coffee,
Arizona Bay

Saturday, May 24, 2008

Oh yeah...

Forgot to mention something.

Drew, the twisted fuck, suggested today that Yes should hook up with Wham and do a song called Wakeman Up Before You Go-Go. Then he kept playing that damn hook from it on the keyboard.

Yes, you know what I'm doing on top of Play That Funky Music tonight. Christ, I might as well don the pink skirt and suck a big cock right now. We are such repressed little faggots...

Love,
Arizona Bay

Head, Removed

That insane letter I wrote my new favorite author? He wrote me a reply. A wonderful, encouraging, brain-frying reply that just made my entire fucking day.

Happy as fuck,
Arizona Bay